Итоги конкурса Film 15-го КМФР
Оргкомитет КМФР начинает обещанные ранее публикации рейтингов всех конкурсных работ, поданных на фестиваль. Первыми свои оценки узнают участники конкурса Film.
Рейтинг каждой работы образован как среднее значение оценок членов жюри конкурса, к которому могли быть добавлены баллы от Executive jury (каждый член жюри мог увеличить оценку на один балл). Решение о том, с какой оценкой работа проходит в шорт-лист, также принималось судьями Executive jury. В конкурсе Film этот порог составил 51+ балл, бронзовые награды начинались от 59+ баллов, серебряные – от 63+, обладатели золота набрали 71 и более баллов.
Максим Лазебник, продюсер КМФР: " Несколько простых тезисов. Бесспорных решений не бывает. Мы не считаем, что система оценки работ членами жюри КМФР безупречна. Но она максимально прозрачна. Фестиваль должен нести пользу всем участникам, а не только победителям. Целый ряд фестивалей постсоветского пространства по факту оперирует примерно одним и тем же составом участников и победителей. В этом должен быть какой-то смысл, кроме доходов организаторов и рейтинговых очков для победителей. Полученное значение баллов для всех конкурсных работ, в том числе и не выбившихся в призеры, призвано помочь всем конкурсантам в работе над своими ошибками и способствовать их последующим победам».
Agency Entry Series Online jury Executive jury Award A-1 Foods Praktika Pro A-01-01 SPY 28 - - Voskhod creative agency A-01-02 Happy Village 46 54 (46+8) short TBWA\UKRAINE A-01-03 Petition 32 - - BBDO Russia Group A-01-04 Taste 30 - - Ogilvy & Mather Ukraine A-01-05 Dobrynia — Moo-moo 57 - short Utopia A-01-06 DESIGNER 34 - - PROVID A-01-07 Overcaring mother 54 59 (54+5) bronze Arriba! A-01-08 Yarmarka. Kitchen 30 - - Voskhod creative agency A-01-09 Dancer 41 - - Kinograf A-01-10 LIMO. Zebras 32 - - Ogilvy & Mather Ukraine A-01-11 Chumak — Thank you 41 - - Havas Worldwide Kiev A-01-12 Running Things 29 - - THINKMcCANN A-01-13 Love in Supermarket Nasha Ryaba. The choice of Ukrainian Families 28 - - THINKMcCANN A-01-14 Men’s Business Nasha Ryaba. The choice of Ukrainian Families 23 - - THINKMcCANN A-01-15 First word Nasha Ryaba. The choice of Ukrainian Families 30 - - Saatchi & Saatchi Ukraine A-01-16 Leopard Leopard 16 - - Navigator DDB LM-A-01-01 Fishing Provansal EZHK 31 - - Navigator DDB LM-A-01-02 The Shop Provansal EZHK 29 - - Navigator DDB LM-A-01-03 Natural control Provansal EZHK 27 - - A-2 Non-Alcoholic Drinks Red Pepper A-02-01 Hangover is over 27 - - Great Advertising Group A-02-02 Chaevik 24 - - Ogilvy & Mather Ukraine A-02-03 Chumak — Fruzi 27 - - BBDO Ukraine A-02-04 Daddy cool 40 - - ESSE Production House A-02-05 Loop 71 - gold Publicis Visage A-02-06 Non Stop Night. Quarrel Non Stop Day & Night 47 55 (47+8) short Publicis Visage A-02-07 Non Stop Day. Sweater Non Stop Day & Night 45 Publicis Visage A-02-08 Non Stop Day. Net Non Stop Day & Night 47 A-3 Alcoholic Drinks Kinograf A-03-01 GRAIN COLLECTION. Klasychna 23 - - Kinograf A-03-02 GRAIN COLLECTION. Zhytnya 24 - - Havas Worldwide Kazakhstan A-03-03 Stone Age TV Set 36 - - Aimbulance A-03-04 Goldberg Machine for Khortytsya 31 - - Saatchi & Saatchi Ukraine A-03-05 Kaputt 23 - - A-4 Household CreativePeople A-04-01 VitrA Realove 45 53 (45+8) short A-6 Home Electronics & Audio-Visual Leo Burnett Moscow A-06-01 How Much Is the Fish? 36 - - A-7 Health & Beauty Yasno A-07-01 Goog Food 17 - - THINKMcCANN A-07-02 Great Sedative 38 - - THINKMcCANN A-07-03 Hare 30 - - Gulliver Cinema A-07-04 Medihronal 19 - - AdShot Creative A-07-05 Canephron N 10 - - A-8 Fashion and other consumer goods RTA A-08-01 A dress-transformer from Avon 22 - - A-10 Entertainment , Leisure, Travel banda agency A-10-01 Ads that make me mad 66 73 (66+7) gold Red Pepper A-10-02 Aquapaaaaark! 32 - - Piko A-10-03 Are you ready for America? 29 - - Not Perfect Y&R I Vilnius A-10-04 Cinema Spring 46 51 (46+5) short Yasno A-10-05 obstetrician Tip&Top 20 - - Yasno A-10-06 spetsnaz Tip&Top 20 - - Yasno A-10-07 miner Tip&Top 18 - - Yasno A-10-08 stripper Tip&Top 18 - - A-11 Consumer & retail services BBDO Russia Group A-11-01 Canyon 69 78 (69+9) grand prix of the Film Contrapunto A-11-02 Сaviar 36 - - Friends Moscow A-11-03 Farewell 54 61 (54+7) bronze A-12 Telecommunications services Voskhod creative agency A-12-01 Telecard Sadness 43 - - Leo Burnett Moscow A-12-02 Write, Watch, Create Your Own Olympic History 34 - - Adventa Lowe A-12-03 Edelweiss 32 - - Adventa Lowe A-12-04 Kite 38 - - Adventa Lowe A-12-05 Sisters 38 - - Utopia A-12-06 FANS OF BIG BILLS 33 - - Utopia A-12-07 SHOUTING 35 - - Utopia A-12-08 SOLDIERS 47 51 (47+4) short Streetart A-12-09 Words change the world 45 54 (45+9) short Red A-12-10 Beeline Artist 37 - - Contrapunto A-12-11 Cafe 46 51 (46+5) short GForce/Grey A-12-12 Bouncers 39 - - Contrapunto A-12-13 New Year Greetings 44 - - Contrapunto A-12-14 Fast Autumn 57 63 (57+6) silver B.I.T.A. Advertising A-12-15 Oculist 38 - - B.I.T.A. Advertising A-12-16 Blackmail 20 - - Not Perfect | Y&R Riga A-12-17 ZELTA ZIVTINA. ZOMBIE 35 - - Not Perfect | Y&R Riga A-12-18 VELCOM. FAMILY CURRENCY 33 - - Yasno A-12-19 CAR clik-clik 32 - - Yasno A-12-20 items clik-clik 29 - - Kinograf A-12-21 300 calls MOTIVE ABOVE THE RULES 37 - - Kinograf A-12-22 The roof MOTIVE ABOVE THE RULES 35 - - Kinograf A-12-23 Performance MOTIVE ABOVE THE RULES 34 - - Kinograf A-12-24 Brother`s inheritance MOTIVE ABOVE THE RULES 38 - - SCHOLZ & FRIENDS KYIV A-12-25 Volia Bundle. Panda Towards new discoveries with Volia 34 - - SCHOLZ & FRIENDS KYIV A-12-26 Volia Bundle. Sky Diver Towards new discoveries with Volia 33 - - Contrapunto A-12-27 Waking up Mobile internet 41 - - Contrapunto A-12-28 Waiting Mobile internet 53 - short Contrapunto A-12-29 Game Internet modem 43 - - Contrapunto A-12-30 Interesting movie Internet modem 43 - - SLAVA A-12-31 Babushka Passion 42 - - SLAVA A-12-32 FOLLOW ME Passion 43 - - BBDO Russia Group A-12-33 Return New plan Smart 39 - - BBDO Russia Group A-12-34 A meaning of life New plan Smart 40 - - BBDO Russia Group A-12-35 Man New plan Smart 45 51 (45+6) short BBDO Russia Group A-12-36 Chic New plan Smart 38 - - INSTINCT A-12-37 Polecat Switch to ZERO 40 - - INSTINCT A-12-38 Beard Switch to ZERO 41 - - INSTINCT A-12-39 Silence Switch to ZERO 33 - - Not Perfect | Y&R Riga A-12-40 ZELTA ZIVTINA. NAME CHANGE ZELTA ZIVTINA. RELAUNCH SERIES 50 55 (50+5) short Not Perfect | Y&R Riga A-12-41 ZELTA ZIVTINA. MEETING ZELTA ZIVTINA. RELAUNCH SERIES 46 Navigator DDB LM-A-12-01 Honesty 1 Honesty Campaign 48 45 Navigator DDB LM-A-12-02 Honesty 2 Honesty Campaign 45 45 Navigator DDB LM-A-12-03 Honesty 3 Honesty Campaign 45 45 Navigator DDB LM-A-12-04 Honesty pre-roll Honesty Campaign 42 - - A-13 Banking, Investment & Insurance Peachline A-13-01 Shadows 23 - - Peachline A-13-02 Squares 19 - - Kinograf A-13-03 Competition 27 - - Utopia A-13-04 RSA Police 39 - - Hungry Boys A-13-05 Time to call a spade a spade! 24 - - SLAVA A-13-06 Here people decide, not paper 45 54 (45+9) short GForce/Grey A-13-07 Antonio Banderas, bank manager 42 - - DDB Warsaw A-13-08 «Closet» The Three Musketeers 26 - - DDB Warsaw A-13-09 «Adventure» The Three Musketeers 25 - - DDB Warsaw A-13-10 «In front of you» The Three Musketeers 26 - - A-15 Corporate Image TBWAMoscow A-15-01 Jail Chess Cup. Bread 37 - - TBWAMoscow A-15-02 Jail Chess Cup. Note. 42 - - SLAVA A-15-03 Here people decide, not paper 44 - - SLAVA A-15-04 Babushka Passion 43 - - SLAVA A-15-05 FOLLOW ME Passion 42 - - A-16 Social advertising, Fundraising, Donations and Appeals Zavod A-16-01 Pictograms 42 - - MOOZ! A-16-02 If You Drink, Don't Drive! 25 - - Edward Berezin A-16-03 Birthday 33 - - Not Perfect Y&R I Vilnius A-16-04 Without Bullying 43 - - Leo Burnett Moscow A-16-05 The Bubble Fund Bela Children 44 56 (49+7) short Leo Burnett Moscow A-16-06 The Turtleneck Fund Bela Children 45 Leo Burnett Moscow A-16-07 The Tights Fund Bela Children 49 Hungry Boys A-16-08 Helpless Machine Helpless Machine 41 - - THINKMcCANN A-16-09 Teddy Bear The Victory Day of Human Values 25 - - THINKMcCANN A-16-10 Shawl The Victory Day of Human Values 25 - - THINKMcCANN A-16-11 Cherry Tree The Victory Day of Human Values 25 - - A-17 Internet Film Svetly Story A-17-01 Yandex.Images: Advanced Image Search 31 - - Grape A-17-02 7UP — DEAD SUMMER 41 - - Leo Burnett Moscow A-17-03 How Much Is the Fish? 40 - - MOST Creative Club A-17-04 Olympic Changes 53 removed wrong category banda agency A-17-05 Ads that make me mad 55 57 (55+2) short Aimbulance A-17-06 Goldberg Machine for Khortytsya 33 - - Hungry Boys A-17-07 Helpless machine 31 - - PROVID A-17-08 Loop 60 68 (60+8) silver TBWAMoscow A-17-09 VISA FIFA 26 - - Havas Worldwide Ukraine A-17-10 Anti-zombie-effect 34 - - Fastway A-17-11 Yandex.Direct New Year’s eve video 55 59 (55+4) bronze Branson Digital A-17-12 Portrait 28 - - SCHOLZ & FRIENDS KYIV A-17-13 VOLIA Smart HD. Father Название серии VOLIA Smart HD. Life is too short… 36 - - SCHOLZ & FRIENDS KYIV A-17-14 VOLIA Smart HD. Train Название серии VOLIA Smart HD. Life is too short… 29 - - SCHOLZ & FRIENDS KYIV A-17-15 VOLIA Smart HD. Robbery Название серии VOLIA Smart HD. Life is too short… 31 - - Michurin, creative agency A-17-16 Cosa Nostra Cosa Nostra.Al Solone 30 - - Michurin, creative agency A-17-17 Cosa Nostra Cosa Nostra.Al Solone 29 - - Michurin, creative agency A-17-18 Cosa Nostra Cosa Nostra.Al Solone 29 - - Navigator DDB LM-A-17-01 The Music of Dust 58 58 short A-18 Corporate film AG-VIDEO A-18-01 AEP GROUP 17 - - AG-VIDEO A-18-02 AEP 17 - - Red Keds A-18-03 Video for Nissan 38 - - A-19 Promo videos, TV programs and movies, radio intros and announces tv channel «Inter» A-19-01 Vail 52 57 (55+2) short tv channel «Inter» A-19-02 One family 30 - - Streetart A-19-03 Malina.am 32 - - tv channel «Inter» A-19-04 Thank you that they don*t know.(bombarduvannya) Thank you that they don*t know. 53 67 (57+10) silver tv channel «Inter» A-19-05 Thank you that they don*t know (konctabir) Thank you that they don*t know. 53 tv channel «Inter» A-19-06 Thank you that they don*t (payok) Thank you that they don*t know. 57 tv channel «Inter» A-19-07 Concerns everyone .(father) Concerns everyone 47 56 (47+9) short tv channel «Inter» A-19-08 Concerns everyone (girl) Concerns everyone 41 - - A-20 Ads for digital monitors indoor and outdoor advertising, mobile phones etc Red Pepper A-20-01 Aqapaaaaaaaark! 32 - -
